Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Hi guys,

I'm busy with Academy's Abrams so I thought i'd just give a quick pitoral history of progress up to 2 days ago and then I'll continue with progress here. I'm building this for a GB on another site so some of you may have seen this before.

Startup.....

M1A101.jpg

Plenty of filling needed....

M1A105.jpg

M1A104.jpg

Especially on the turret...

M1A108.jpg

but after plenty milliput and a primer coat....

M1A109.jpg

Replaced the cross struts on the turret basket because they were too straight....

turr02.jpg

And the turret is now ready for primer....

turret01.jpg

Turret02.jpg

Turret03.jpg

Cheers

Geoff

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 4 weeks later...
Phantomconsturctor... what's wrong with the Tamiya M1?

Geoff... great job so far...

-Greg

first of all let me say awsome work on this kit. i like how you took the time to redo all the tiedowns, and i cannot wait to see it done.

tamiya was the first m-1 kit to be released,(m-1 not m-1a1) and the desert storm and ods releases (m-1a1 and m-1a2) are just reissues. the toolings were not updaed enough.

the tamiya turret and ods details are great, but the hull stinks, small details missing. the rear drive sprocket is one of my biggest gripes, it is not spoked.

since i bought mine for the accessories it makes me mad that academy comes with the extended turret basket. plus i like academy accessories.

for the money, i like this new tool academy one the best so far. i wish i waited to buy this one before i bought four tamiya ones.

sorry to hijack the thread.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Looking Great Jug! I won the earlier boxing for this kit at a club comp the other day! Just got a barrel and stowage and PE for it the other day! Just have to get some different Tracks thou... Were did you get your ones from?

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 2 weeks later...
for the money, i like this new tool academy one the best so far. i wish i waited to buy this one before i bought four tamiya ones.

Sorry, but that is not a true statement at all.

Yes, you get a few extra pieces and updated pieces in the Academy kit, but the rest is junk. The turret is incorrect since they used their original M1 turret which is 5mm too short in the front. The hull is exactly the same as the Tamiya hull. The tracks are the old style T156 tracks which haven't been used since before ODS ('90-'91) plus the center guide teeth are incorrectly molded in the center of each track block as opposed to between them. The overall detail is rather soft. The rear is missing the extra louver on the lower lip. The flange for the exhaust stack is incomplete. The decals are fiction and are totally wrong for an M1A1 (the 4ID decals belong to an M1A2, the USMC ones do not exist). Etc., etc., etc. I would buy it and use the new J sprue with the new and updated parts and trash the rest of it.

Here is a review of the Academy one to back up what I say.

All other current M1A1 kits are actually better, with the Tamiya M1A1/A2 kit only coming in third behind the newer Dragon M1A1 AIM and M1A2 SEP kits. For the money, Tamiyas is actually the best buy since it allows you to build an Army M1A1HC, M1A2, or a USMC M1A1HC. It is the only kit that gives you all 3 options.

If your only concern is the mud relief holes on the rear sprockets, they are pretty easy to add w/a drill bit and a round file. The Tamiya kit may not be the best, but it is pretty good and comes with some nice added pieces...Oh yeah, its pretty accurate too.

Edited by HeavyArty
Link to post
Share on other sites
first of all let me say awsome work on this kit. i like how you took the time to redo all the tiedowns, and i cannot wait to see it done.

tamiya was the first m-1 kit to be released,(m-1 not m-1a1) and the desert storm and ods releases (m-1a1 and m-1a2) are just reissues. the toolings were not updaed enough.

the tamiya turret and ods details are great, but the hull stinks, small details missing. the rear drive sprocket is one of my biggest gripes, it is not spoked.

since i bought mine for the accessories it makes me mad that academy comes with the extended turret basket. plus i like academy accessories.

for the money, i like this new tool academy one the best so far. i wish i waited to buy this one before i bought four tamiya ones.

sorry to hijack the thread.

Sadly the academy M1 is little better than the tamiya one. The trumpeter M1s are also just is bad.they all have turret shape issues andhull detail issues. In terms of accuracy the newer Drago M1A1AIM and M1A2 SEP are literally almost 100% accurate.

Great work on polishing up the academy one though. If you are interested in doing another i highly recommend the dragon offerings.

Link to post
Share on other sites
I just picked up this kit. This is the right version for a modern USMC battle tank, yes? I've never done armor. Any major pitfalls to look out for? VG

The basic model is correct for a USMC tank. You have to swap the smoke grenade launchers out for USMC ones which have 8 individual tubes. You can see them below. Some have the mounting bars for the Missile Countermeasure Device (MCD) too, as the pic has. Tamiya's M1A1/A2 kit has the USMC parts in it too.

1581559810_3f68ba88f5.jpg

Edited by HeavyArty
Link to post
Share on other sites
The basic model is correct for a USMC tank. You have to swap the smoke grenade launchers out for USMC ones which have 8 individual tubes. You can see them below. Some have the mounting bars for the Missile Countermeasure Device (MCD) too, as the pic has. Tamiya's M1A1/A2 kit has the USMC parts in it too.

1581559810_3f68ba88f5.jpg

Cool, thanks for the feedback. Also, I'm looking into an aftermarket "stowage" set up. Any opinions on which may be be better than another? Thanks again. VG

Link to post
Share on other sites
Cool, thanks for the feedback. Also, I'm looking into an aftermarket "stowage" set up. Any opinions on which may be be better than another? Thanks again. VG

AEF designs makes some good stuff. Check them out at aefdesigns.com. Also I think Legend makes a pretty accurate stowage set for a OIF tank. Make sure you pick up their recent release, not the orginal set that includes an APU. See link below.

http://www.www-legend.co.kr/01_afv01.html?...age=&spage=

Link to post
Share on other sites
AEF designs makes some good stuff. Check them out at aefdesigns.com. Also I think Legend makes a pretty accurate stowage set for a OIF tank. Make sure you pick up their recent release, not the orginal set that includes an APU. See link below.

http://www.www-legend.co.kr/01_afv01.html?...age=&spage=

Very cool. Exactly what I had in mind. Thanks. VG

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 weeks later...
I think he mean't the basket bottoms. I'd like to know also. Very nice.

Been away from this kit for a while but back from tonight. Sorry for rudely not answering sooner guys but it's that damn life getting in the way again. Paul and Aaron - the mesh is photo etch from Aber. They make various patterns and they come in a sheet about 80 X 50 mm (you figuer the inches).

Dave - the tracks I got from my local hobby store as you see in the very first pic they are made by AFV club and they are fantastic and reasonably well priced.

Tonight I will be spraying the turret so pics tomorrow.

Cheers

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...